Fictional: a made-up site for Fruitful’s example. Nothing here is real.

That Orange Sitelinks for curious people
I didn't, and that's a fair point. I switched brands in March. The index keeps the old one for continuity, so it measures what my habits from last August would cost now, which is a slightly different question from what I'm actually spending. I track both, and the second number is lower.
That's the right way to do it. Most people who try this only track one, then argue with the official figure about the wrong thing.

Back to the discussion